Those pesky buttons

Many of you have been asking for some correspondence regarding the button position in the window manager.

Here it is.

At Ubuntu we have a golden opportunity not only to make our OS as good as the competition but to make it better. The button position discussion and analysis started with:

- Why do Mac OS and Windows have the buttons where they do?

- What was the functional reason behind the Mac OS choice (or the Windows position for that matter)?

- Why, when most application menus are top left should the window controls go top right?

- Why, when we read left to right is the most destructive action first?

- Are we smoking crack to think that the learning curve for getting used to a new position is ever going to be worth any real or perceived benefit of new positions?

As part of a major theme update it felt appropriate to ask these questions.

After the internal debate and analysis (which went something like the picture below) we decided to put this version in the theme and to use it. I have had it running on my machine with the buttons in this order since before the Portland sprint (first week of February?) and I am quite used to it.

Is it better or worse?

It is quite hard to tell. The theme has been in the alpha since Friday.  Now that you have had a chance to use it what do you think?

Personally, I would have the max and min on the left and close on the right.

Posted in general | Tagged , | 34 Comments

Reasons to celebrate: 4th March 2010

My first year working for Canonical draws to a close with my team delivering a new identity for Ubuntu.

I am very proud of the result and would like to thank them for all their hard work. I also want to thank Mark Shuttleworth and Jane Silber for setting out the challenge and for being part of the team.

Ubuntu has a great engineering heritage. It is fast and efficient. Ubuntu gives the world an excellent free and open-source operating system that helps many millions of people achieve their goals. This new identity gives Ubuntu an opportunity to stand up and be noticed. It gives all of us more to enjoy as we work and play.

If Ubuntu were a person it would be that person at the dinner party with great stories and a mind brimming with knowledge; the person you know will enjoy learning from. They know things you want to know, they do things you want to do; you want to be like them because they are amazing!

I am not going to wax lyrical on the meeting of form and function. Many others have written and spoken on that subject. This is a moment for celebration.

We have before us the very finest cloth. Let’s make sure our Ubuntu turns up to the dinner party in the coolest gear!

There is much to do.

Posted in general | Tagged , , | 8 Comments

Ending Poverty with Open Hardware

The Hexayurt is a new kind of sheltering solution. To make the simplest hexayurt, make a wall by putting six sheets of plywood on their sides in a hexagon. Cut six more sheets in half diagonally, and screw them together into a shallow cone. Lift the roof on to the wall with a large group of people, then fasten it down with more screws. Seal and paint it for durability. Your basic hexayurt is complete. This shelter will last for years in most climates and costs less than $100. This basic design can be improved with proper windows, doors, room partitions, stove fittings and other architectural features. More durable materials could give it a very long life.

http://hexayurt.com/

I found a little more information on the Science for Humanity site.

And the schematics on Appropedia.

Posted in Open Source, humanity | Tagged , | 3 Comments

Excuse me!?

Excuse me!?

Excuse me!?

Posted in Ubuntu | Tagged | 5 Comments

A bug in two parts

I finally got round to going through the photos on my camera this morning – I still haven’t got round to putting my holiday (August holiday!) photos on Flickr so I thought this could be the way to spend a chilly Saturday morning.

F-spot error

F-spot error

As is obvious from the image, something went wrong. In fact two things went wrong:
1) The error message itself: an f-spot bug?
2) The dialog box is too wide to read the message or see the buttons: a GTK bug?

To report the bug I needed a screen shot which I then wanted to upload to my flickr acc

Wide dialog

Wide dialog

Another example of 1) and 2) above except that in this case it is not the error message that is too long but rather there is simply too much detail. Please do let me look for every possible version of an image file but there is almost no benefit, at this stage, of showing me the full list. Accuracy is not always useful.

I did a quick Google and really wasn’t sure where to report the bugs so I thought I would document them quickly here and trust that someone can tell me where I need to file these bugs or add my support to them being fixed.

Help?

Posted in Ubuntu | Tagged , , | 5 Comments

The most beautiful blog post ever*

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I would like to share with you the short-list for the Ubuntu Karmic Koala Wallpaper’s Competition.

We had so many fantastic entries and so little space on the final CD. At last count, 19 fabulous wallpapers made it onto the final image!

I can’t thank everyone enough for their fantastic contributions. I wish there had been space for more and maybe, with a little help and some technical cleverness we can make it easier for people to select directly from the pool; good idea?

Below are the images that made it into the final selection. If your favourite isn’t on the CD it will be made available as a separate package!

Now, what shall we do for Lucid?

*until Ubuntu 10.04, of course!

Posted in Ubuntu | Tagged , , | 4 Comments

Eating Linux every day

Designer? Thought about Linux but just not sure? Then this is for you:

http://thoughtlounge.squarespace.com/linux-eats/

Posted in Open Source, design | Tagged , | 3 Comments

Open Source Matters

This week’s edition of the IET magazine is The Open Source Issue. The arrival of my weekly magazine seemed to coincide beautifully with @leisa tweeting the question: “Why does open source matter?”

In the magazine we have: open source biotechnology, open source cars, open source phones and the story of how AQA (a UK examination board) went open source.

“Open source biotech?”, I hear you ask yourselves. Well, yes, I did wonder.

In my opinion, one of the most important aspects of open source principals is that open source represents the unencumbered flow of ideas. Imagine where the world might be if the first person to work out how to light a fire had done it in secret.

A close second is the idea that lots of brains working on the same problem is a good thing. Very few individuals are great enough to to be brilliant in isolation.

The biotech example is interesting. The biotech world uses patents to encourage innovation as it enables inventors to make some cash from their ideas. The problem is that good ideas, useful information gets stuck in “EvilCos” library and progress can, in some cases get stalled.

Open source may not be the answer to all the world’s woes but it provides a framework for a freedom to collaborate on solving problems that affect all of us.

One of the participants we had in for usability testing was a very impressive young woman of 23. She was studying for her masters in neuroscience and, I quote “I was going to cure Parkinson’s but someone beat me to it so I need to find a new disease”. I may not be able to provide her with research she can build on, but I can contribute to ensuring the interfaces she uses don’t get in her way.

Posted in Open Source, Ubuntu | Tagged | Leave a comment

Seriously though, why would anyone do this?

I tweeted (twittered? Will I never know?) a link to this article on how to run Ubuntu on a mac.

Within moments I got a direct tweet back from a former colleague who is a UX/Design person:

Seriously with OSx as good as it is… Why would anyone do this? I don’t get it.

Why run Ubuntu on a mac?

The article I linked to provides some suggestions but here are a few of my own:

  1. Because a basic Ubuntu install lets you do shed loads more than a basic Mac install. Ubuntu is not just an OS; it is a Linux distribution that comes with an enormous amount of free to share and use software.
  2. Because we would like to invite you to our party. Ubuntu is there for everyone to use. No exceptions.
  3. Because you want to help us make it better?

How about that for a start?

Posted in Open Source, Ubuntu | Tagged , | 5 Comments

Living beauty

Reading Roger Scruton’s essay in The Times made me think. I like that. The title of the article is ‘What has art got to do with beauty?’ – in a time of Turner prizes – a very interesting question I am sure you will agree.

The article raises many interesting points and rather than dilute, I shall only address one of them at this time.

This search for aesthetic order is not just a luxury; it is essential to life in society. It is one way in which we send out signals of humility, and show that we are not just animals foraging for our needs but civilised beings who wish to live at peace with our neighbours. That is why we adopt dress codes; it is why we are guided by taste in our language, in our gestures and in our ways of looking at other people and inviting them into our lives.

Mr Scruton himself brings modern architecture and ’starchitects’ to attention.

‘Form follows function’ is often heard during design related conversations and I don’t think the function of form is examined regularly enough.

Returning, for a second, to Scruton’s point about architecture:

But the controversy over modern architecture remains real and important: for it reflects the need of ordinary people that appearances be respected, so that the place where they find themselves can also be shared as a home.

This need for beauty in our lives extends to the websites we use, the products we buy and the software we interact with. Apple brings us great attention to form and certainly presents products which ‘can be shared as a home’ and, while I don’t necessarily agree that every Apple product is infinitely usable, the particular attention to the aesthetic does ensure that Apple products are ‘welcomed into our lives’.

How on earth can we invite beauty into design and not get caught up in endless subjective debates?

Beauty
–noun, plural -ties.
the quality present in a thing or person that gives intense pleasure or deep satisfaction to the mind, whether arising from sensory manifestations (as shape, color, sound, etc.), a meaningful design or pattern, or something else (as a personality in which high spiritual qualities are manifest).

I am going to assume that we all endeavour to come up with a good solution to every design problem and imagine we ask ourselves something like:

  • Does my solution fulfil its function?
  • Does my solution represent and excellent execution of my skills? (be they, software design, graphic design, interaction design, etc)

Perhaps all we need to add is:

  • Does this solution give intense pleasure and deep satisfaction to its intended audience?

By adding that final question, it seems to me, we will indeed be giving the world exactly what it craves, beauty.

Posted in design, technology | 1 Comment